Your Very Life

Living where Life is

Month: March 2017

Reflections on Immigration and Deportation (Part 3)

[This is the last in a series of posts to probe thinking and responses on this issue. Click to access Parts 1 & 2. Keep thinking, stretching, learning and growing.]

6) Consider fear

Any time you have a group of people who have no recourse to due process means you have less freedom as a country. That’s why we rationally need to address what to do with the 11+million people who are here illegally: We do not want a permanent underclass.

The human temptation to exploit is too real for us to take this lightly. Employers who know workers won’t complain will be tempted to abuse them. Landlords who know tenants are at their mercy can become derelict.

Moreover, you do not want a group of people who view the police with suspicion or the government as the enemy. This is common sense. But for someone who is afraid of being deported, the officer’s uniform is to be feared.

Another glimpse of life: An American woman fell in love with and married a Mexican man who was here illegally. They had several children and opened 4 restaurants in the Midwest. He was deported, and they have not seen him since. The children are growing up without their father. The wife has lost 3 of the restaurants. And the government adhered to the letter of the Law and oversaw the destruction of a family, jobs for dozens of servers, and great places to eat.

This is one story of many. It seems to me that we are better than that as a country. Yes, if that person had not been here illegally there would have been a different outcome. But, that person was an integral part of the flourishing of his community. Is deportation really the best solution?

7) Consider Scripture & the Gospel

Three quick thoughts from Scripture.

“Sojourners in your midst.” There are several references in the Law of Moses to the treatment of sojourners. It’s always with a view to their protection and the extension of mercy to them. God is saying that a people who please him will take care with those who are aliens and most subject to danger: When a stranger sojourns with you in your land, you shall not do him wrong. You shall treat the stranger who sojourns with you as the native among you, and you shall love him as yourself, for you were strangers in the land of Egypt. I am the Lord your God. (Lv 19:33-34) This verse is but an example of the heart of God: take care to be kind, just and compassionate to the sojourner.

“Do unto others what you’d have them do to you.” Jesus is stark here in Matthew 7:12. It’s true. It’s convicting. And, it’s just this simple. If I lived in a violent place with no future prospects, would I want a neighboring country to invite me in to do the back-breaking work (i.e., mutually beneficial) or not?

Extending grace always beats exacting justice. This is hard for us, because there is just so much injustice in the world. But, with the Lord, an open, gracious hand always trumps exacting justice to the letter of the Law. A country that will deny grace to those needing it will find less grace abroad in its land. A county that extends grace—even if, for a time, it is taken advantage of—is a country where grace will continue to grow.

This is not “throw open the prisons, because we show grace.” No. People ought to be held accountable for their wrongs. But, by now we have seen that with change of status, with dishonest handlers, with extreme poverty in the home country and ready jobs here, with employers hiring people who are undocumented (anchoring them here)… well, there’s so much more nuance than simply to call everyone ‘illegal’ who is undocumented. And to treat everyone en masse.

The thing about grace is that it is uniquely a divine trait. Only God originates grace. Every act of grace on earth has the same source. Therefore it is in never-ending supply. The more grace you give, the more grace you have to give, and the more grace is in play. This works on the level of countries, too. Think of the after-effects of World Wars 1 & 2: After WW1, The Treaty or Versailles exacted extreme reparations from Germany, and set the stage for another war 21 years later. After WW2, the Marshall Plan for Europe (and its equivalent for Japan) saw the quickest turnaround of destroyed enemies into vibrant allies that the world has ever known. It was a display of grace in the political sphere.

Can we think there is a grace-filled solution to our problem? Do we think we have to support deportation or else we’ll be denying the rule of law? Is there a creative third-way through this dilemma? I think so.

Consider each person as a person with dignity and potential. Consider each person’s past: (a) the universal longing for a better life, (b) their status (which is not ‘one size fits all’), and (c) the contribution they’ve made since they’ve been here. I think on balance, we can figure out a way to address their immigration status in a way that upholds the rule of law, while seeing the potential increase they bring to our country.


Based on these considerations, might God grant believers like you and me a different outlook than what Left or Right are serving up?

Reflections on Immigration and Deportation (Part 2)

[Part 2 of 3 – to get us thinking, growing and engaging in the public sphere. To read part 1, click here. We pick it up in the middle of several considerations believers should make when thinking about the individuals and the issue as a whole. Part 3 will be published later today. Leave a comment–graciously–to push back, ask questions, encourage or bring new insights!]

3) Consider the cultural increase

Lamentably, during the 2016 campaign, now-President Trump played on prejudices by calling Mexicans “rapists, criminals” etc. He has since gone out of his way to differentiate between the criminal element and the industrious element in the Hispanic community, and he’s praised their contribution to our economic growth. This has been lost on those at both ends of the political spectrum: the Nativists (who want to keep America for Americans) and the Left (who only hear Trump say what they want him to say).

The fact is that the overwhelming majority of the Latin Americans who come to this country are coming seeking a better life. They are prepared to work hard to enjoy the freedom and prosperity that are available here. They are future- and family-oriented (wanting to give their children a better life), and they hold traditional values (with a strong Catholic ties).

Honestly, if I were designing the type of people I’d want to populate our country, these would fit the bill. Hardworking, industrious, family-focused, with traditional values.

It seems to me that they are models for whom to have flowing into the country. If only their status were not an issue.

Is there a way to solve that very real ‘illegal status’? To me, because they are the types of people who will change the future, it’s worth us finding that way.

4) Consider the economic increase

People know where jobs are, and they go where jobs are, and they get a job. It’s the law of supply and demand, and it’s how economies work: those willing to move for work will get it. At the moment of their employment, they are contributing to your life and mine, and our economy. Farms, factories, constructions sites, etc. We now reap the benefits of their illegal labor. The US economy grows because more people are able to produce and have the means to consume.

Are they taking jobs from Americans? It’s hard to think so when the jobless rate is under 5% (which is the traditional line for “full employment”) and the economy is in the longest growth cycle for 50 years (over 90 months of growth, as of Feb 2017). Rather than taking jobs from others, they are contributing to the growth of the economy.

Are they doing work that no one wants? Yes. The alternative to their labor in these jobs is higher pay for these jobs and thus, higher prices for the food harvested, goods manufactured. This statement is not a blanket excuse for illegal immigration. But it’s a reminder to those who want wholesale deportation that this will radically change many aspects of our economy.

On taxes & use of public services: I honestly don’t know if they ‘pay their way’. You can find studies and reports to say whatever you want. So I don’t know if they currently pay their way. But I know this: they sure will if they prosper, and they never will if they remain poor. It’s in our best interest to help them prosper.

However, every dollar spent at Walmart, Piggly Wiggly & Amazon is taxed, no matter who spends it. Every rent check pays the property tax on that rental unit. Every employee paid with a fake SS number contributes to Social Security, and they’ll never get that back. Every employee paid has federal and state taxes deducted at source. If that is with a fake social security number, they’ll never file taxes to get returns the tax code grants to workers.

Schools and Emergency Rooms. “They are using these services without paying for them.” Except they are paying sales taxes, property taxes, and income taxes; it’s not anything near a ‘free-ride’ indicated in that statement.

5) Consider who else is implicated

If an employer hires an undocumented worker to work for him or her, that employer is as culpable as the worker. There’s no way around this. Even if an employer is presented with a SS number, there’s a good chance in farming, construction, etc., that the potential worker is undocumented. We are unjust if we speak only of ‘illegal immigrants’ and not also of ‘illegal employers.’

If the employer pays cash, or fails to live up to employment standards in any way (i.e., paying them less than minimum wage, making them work beyond what the law allows, threatening them with no recourse), that employer is profiting unduly from their status. That’s called exploitation, which is not only illegal, it’s also immoral.

I have heard many on the Right say with conviction, “but they’ve broken the Law”, and I agree: the Rule of Law is the bedrock of freedom. So is the universal application of the rule of law: Employers who hire undocumented workers must be held to account too.

Second, if citizens at large participate in the benefit of undocumented work—lower prices for homes, building, produce, factory goods—then aren’t we ratifying the working situation? This is why, when the abolitionists in England were working against the slave trade, they shamed England not to use sugar, which was produced by slaves. While we eat the fruit harvested by and drive on roads built by their hands, we are ratifying the situation that brings it about.

[Part 3 is coming later today.]

Reflections on Immigration & Deportation (part 1)

[Part 1 of 3 – to get us thinking, growing, and engaging the public sphere]

“I’ve told my friend Alejandro, if he’s scared, he can come and stay with us.” A friend at Grace told me this recently. Alejandro is his friend and is in the US illegally. The recent focus on the deportation has driven up fear for Alejandro and the millions like him.

My friend was the second person at Grace in the last three weeks who told me the same thing: they are willing to take someone in, so as to protect that person from forcible deportation.

These two brothers, I can quite confidently say, would vote on the conservative side of the political spectrum. They are mature (in Christian faith and in their age category). They are financially successful. In other words, they are not radicals by any political definition.

And yet here they are ready to defy an agency of their government. What’s going on?

It’s time to admit that we need to think afresh about persons who live in the US illegally. And by “we” I mean Believers. Christians. Christ-followers. It’s time for us to step back from the thought patterns of the Left or Right, and change the equation in our thinking. My intent here is to write to believers who consider themselves thoughtful. Let’s be more thoughtful and more creatively thoughtful than what we see in the world. Whether you identify with the Right or the Left, do you have room to grow in your thinking?

It seems to me that you can address a problem either by looking at the problem itself or by looking at the desired outcome. In this case, either you can focus on walls, wait times and quotas, etc., or you can see the bigger question: what kind of country do we want? What kind of atmosphere? What kind of future? What kind of people to populate it? What coheres with Scripture and with our calling? How do we treat people near us? How should we?

Let me make four preliminary comments, and then offer several areas in which we can “consider” better.

First, every sovereign nation has the right and duty to seek the best for its own citizens (though not at the expense of other countries, i.e. conquering a neighbor). A primary role of government is to maintain order and the ability to live peaceably within one’s borders. The other way to say this is to promote “life, liberty and pursuit of happiness” and maintain true justice and human rights.

Second, every nation that flourishes walks in step with God’s ideals for human flourishing. For Christians this is so obvious as to be redundant. A nation that flourishes, then, will highlight justice and integrity, compassion and kindness. These are like 4 wheels on a car: each is needed to drive the car forward.

Third, the United States is based on opportunity, an industrious spirit, merit, ‘blind justice’ (citizens equal before the law because of equal human dignity). The American Dream is not so much prosperity as it is opportunity; not more possessions, but more decision-making power. America has always looked forward—to build a better life, a better nation, a better world. A city on a hill. A place where people dream of coming and achieving untapped potential. As we review the history of the North American Continent, 95% of us are of immigrant stock, and we built the US (and Canada) from wilderness to world leadership because we based it on freedom of the individual to flourish.

Fourth, the two major tragedies of our past are so humiliating because they contradict our ideals: The awful treatment of Native population, and the horror of slavery and its hangover. We have failed our ideals miserably in both these areas. And we’ve failed God’s ideals.

At this moment, we are in danger of allowing within our midst a third human tragedy on a national scale: our ultimate treatment &/or ‘solving’ of the question of the dilemma of undocumented persons in our midst, of illegal immigrants into our border.

The need is urgent for many Christians to think with more creativity. So let us consider together.

1) Consider the individual & their home

Think of a village or town in Mexico or elsewhere in Latin America: Economic prospects are bleak (to put it mildly). The future for your family is tenuous. Mere existence is the daily grind. There’s very little “pursuit of happiness.”

Consider this: of the people in that village, who would embark on a 500-mile mile journey to a distant country for a better life? The ones with courage &/or resourcefulness, those who not only want a better life but who will work to make it happen.

What is their expectation as they start their journey? Perhaps they go with limited knowledge of VISA prospects but hope for the best. Or they go with encouragement of family in the US (“just come, we’ll figure it out”). Maybe there’s a handler who says “I can get you in, for a fee.” Or they know they’re coming illegally.

In those cases where a handler has promised entry: Often the handler will be crooked, and drop them off near the border, obviously without proper paperwork. At that point, the migrant has few choices: enter this dreamed-of land with no papers, remain in the borderland of Mexico (which is not home, has no job prospects, and has a high level of crime), or attempt to make the trek back to one’s home village. It’s not hard to see why people cross illegally.

Perhaps, back in the village, there’s no handler, but there’s a solo trek across Mexico to get to the US. There is a 1½-3 year waiting period to obtain a visa, as of 2011. [] This legal immigration road would entail multiple correspondences with the US embassy/consulate. This might just seem too long in a dead-end home where things never get better.

From our end it’s illegal immigration. I don’t think that’s the overwhelming concern in the village. They are willing to risk anything and everything on a better life. They know that if they get to the US they can get jobs and begin to change their lives.

Perhaps they should think more clearly about immigration status before leaving home. But can you blame them? Stay for a no hope existence; Go for a risky-but-American-Dream future. Get to America and make more in a week than most make in a month, send support back to mom or wife, and ultimately bring your family to America too.

They are simply trying to get out and make a better life. This does not mean that they are in the right to cross the border illegally. But it helps me remember where someone came from and what they came to. They desperately want what we have been born into.

2) Consider change in status

Not all who find themselves in the US illegally came here illegally. Consider this accounting from an attorney friend of mine:

I’ve got a client who came to the United States in 1998 with his wife and his 1 year old son. He left a terrible situation in Mexico. I’m not sure mechanically how they got here. He is diligent, law abiding, fair. He loves his family, has been married to one woman and works hard. Initially, he obtained a work permit and began working as a textile worker. He kept the same job for almost a decade. He and his wife had 3 more children born in the United States. They paid taxes. He had a valid driver’s license. He was never arrested or charged with any violation of law. About 5 years ago, he went to renew his driver’s license and was told that he had to present a social security card in order to renew. He’d had a NC driver’s license for more than a decade. He never was issued a Social Security Number. He tried to get one, but was told that his status in the US was no longer permitted. He could not even apply for a SSN. He has remained in the US…illegally for several years. His only option was to leave the US and apply for entry and then wait or he could stay and do the best he could. He would never abandon his family. He stayed. For years, he kept his nose clean, obeyed the speed limit, worked as a painter for cash (all the while still reporting the income to the IRS, who, by the way, gladly took his money each year). What do we call this man? Is he an illegal? Is it fair to consider him in the same light as someone who, in 2017 may be aware of the illegality of their act, who comes anyway, no matter the reason or justification? 

His status changed, and now he’s undocumented. The laws changed, and now he’s in a shadow bureaucratic existence. What should he do?

[parts 2 & 3 will be published tomorrow – including Scriptural insights. You can “subscribe via email” and get each post delivered to your inbox; see above right]

Of Scuba Gear and Insurance Policies

What is the nature of the gospel? When it comes to you and me, and our interaction with Jesus Christ for salvation, what does that interaction look like in our lives?

Many people think of it like they think of an insurance policy. When you want life insurance, you make a decision to buy it, you pay some money, and then you forget about it… until you are in trouble years later. Too many people think of salvation like this: a one-time decision, go on living your own life, and then when you die you are assured of a good outcome.

This is wrong. It’s not anywhere in Scripture. It’s against the very heart of the gospel message. A better way to think of it is this: you are trapped under water. Doomed. Certain death is moments away. When all of a sudden, from above, comes a scuba diver. He takes off his scuba gear and holds it out to you.

Do you take it? Only if you think there’s air in the tanks. Only if you can see yourself doing the impossible: breathing underwater. Only if you trust the person giving it to you. Only if you want to live.

You grab the mouthpiece, and take a breath. Life. Right now. You put on the tanks, and strap them on to your back. You are wearing the Scuba Gear. You are rescued.

The nature of the gospel is this: you wear it. You put it on. You grab hold of it. For every breath. The gospel isn’t something you think of once, and then get a big payout when you die.

The gospel – God’s love toward in Christ Jesus – is this: you put on the Lord Jesus Christ, and being clothed in him, you are saved from death and doom, and you are assured of a place in God’s everlasting kingdom.

With the scuba gear on, you can work to free yourself from the trapped-ness of being underwater. This too reminds me of the gospel: once we are breathing the air of God’s grace, we have the presence of mind to work at ridding ourselves of the things that trap us and doom us: Secret sins, wrong habits, error-filled thinking, selfish ambition… these will do us in, if we don’t attack them and free ourselves from them. The problem is that we don’t have the power to do this on our own.

But breathing the air of the gospel through the scuba tanks means that we have God’s power to free us from the stuff of life that traps us here.

And, very soon we float up to that place we were created for: just like a regular trapped swimmer can come up to the air they can breathe, so too, God has created us to be with him. And, as we grab hold of that scuba gear called The Gospel it won’t be long until we are breathing the clean, fresh air of the Presence that we were created for.

The gospel changes everything about us. It’s not insurance for one day in the future, it’s Scuba gear for every breath.

If Jesus hasn’t changed your life, then he hasn’t changed your heart.

If he hasn’t changed your heart, then he hasn’t changed your eternity.

Thus, if Christ hasn’t changed your daily life, then you have to ask yourself, has he really changed your eternity?

© 2018 Your Very Life

Theme by Anders NorenUp ↑